Research progress in school refusal of children

doi:10.11852/zgetbjzz2021-0872

Abstract

Abstract: School refusal(SR) is a common psychological behavioral problem in children,which can be manifested by children′s reluctance to go to school,lack of interest in learning and school,or even completely refusing to go to school. More and more studies have shown that most children with school refusal are accompanied by anxiety,depression and other emotional problems,which may have a wide and negative impact on their academic performance,family,interpersonal relationship and other aspects. This review combs the definition,assessment,etiology,treatment and prognosis of school refusal in children,which is helpful for clinicians to further explore the etiology of school refusal in children,and timely assess and intervene to help them improve clinical outcomes and return to school as soon as possible.

Key words: school refusal, definition, assessment, etiology

摘要： 拒绝上学(SR)是儿童常见的心理行为问题之一,主要表现为儿童不愿上学或对学习、学校不感兴趣,甚至完全拒绝去学校。目前越来越多研究表明大多数拒绝上学儿童伴有焦虑、抑郁等情绪问题,对其学业、家庭、人际关系等各方面产生广泛且负面的影响。本文主要综述儿童拒绝上学的定义、评估方法、病因、治疗及预后,有助于临床医生进一步探究拒绝上学儿童的病因并及时地进行评估与干预,帮助其改善临床结局,尽早重返校园。

关键词: 拒绝上学, 定义, 评估, 病因学

CLC Number:

R749.94

ZHOU Ya-nan, YANG Chun, WU Dan-dan. Research progress in school refusal of children[J]. Chinese Journal of Child Health Care, 2022, 30(12): 1354-1357.

周亚男, 杨春, 吴丹丹. 儿童拒绝上学问题的研究进展[J]. 中国儿童保健杂志, 2022, 30(12): 1354-1357.

References

[1] Kearney CA. School refusal behavior in youth:A functional approach to assessment and treatment[M].Washington DC:American Psychological Assiciation,2006:6-85.
[2] 陈玉霞,戴育红,杨升平.广州市中小学生拒绝上学行为调查[J].中国心理卫生杂志,2016,30(2):140-141.
[3] 李玉焕,王立涛. 儿童青少年学校恐惧症的相关因素及心理治疗特点[J].四川精神卫生,2015,28(6):574-577.
[4] Kearnry CA,Albano AM.The functional profiles of school refusal behavior.Diagnostic aspects[J].Behav Modif,2004,28(1):147-161.
[5] Kearnry CA,Cook LC,Chapman G.School stress and school refusal behavior[J].Encyclopedia of Stress(2nd ed),2007:422-425.
[6] Berg I. School avoidance,school phobia,and truancy[M]//Lewis M.Child and adolescent psychiatry:A comprehensive textbook.3rd ed. Sydney:Lippincott Williams & Wilkins,2002:1260-1266.
[7] David H,Malin GL,Glenn M,et al.Differentiation between school attendance problems:Why and how?[J].Cogn Behav Pract,2019,26(1):8-34.
[8] 吴宝铮. 拒绝上学儿童的社交焦虑情绪与养育方式的研究[J].中国药物与临床,2018,18(7):1196-1198.
[9] Kearney CA,Silverman WK.Measuring the function of school refusal behavior:The School Refusal Assessment Scale[J].J Clin Child Psychol,1993,22(1):85-96.
[10] Kearney CA. Identifying the function of school refusal behavior:A Revision of the School Refusal Assessment Scale[J].J Psychopathol Behav,2002,24(4):235-245.
[11] 付敬萍,王旭梅. 拒绝上学评估量表中文版信度和效度分析[C]// 中华医学会全国精神医学学术会议,亚洲神经精神药理学术会议. 2013.
[12] Marie GT,Kamel G.Development and validation of the School Refusal Evaluation Scale for adolescents[J].J Pediatr Psychol,2018,44(2):1-11.
[13] 王旭梅,张莹,何强,等. 儿童青少年拒绝上学原因问卷的编制及信效度检验[J].中华行为医学与脑科学杂志,2012,21(9):853-856.
[14] 陈玉霞,杨升平,戴育红,等. 儿童拒绝上学行为问卷的初步编制[J].中国心理卫生杂志,2015,29(11):843-847.
[15] Allison MA,Attisha E.The link between school attendance and good health[J].Pediatrics,2019,143(2):e20183648.
[16] Gibler RC,Beckmann EA,Lynch-Jordan AM,et al.Characterizing social and academic aspects of school anxiety in pediatric chronic pain[J].Clin J Pain,2019,35(7):625-632.
[17] An R,Yan H,Shi X,et al.Childhood obesity and school absenteeism:A systematic review and meta-analysis[J].Obes Rev,2017,18(12):1412-1424.
[18] 高柏慧,刘果,黄俊峰,等. 青少年拒绝上学行为与气质性格,父母气质性格的关系研究[J].国际精神病学杂志,2016,43(1):10-14.
[19] Romani J,Campredon S,Da DF.School refusal:Psychopathological profiles of adolescents followed in a day hospital setting[J].Arch Pediatr 2017,24(10):950-959.
[20] Munkhaugen EK,Torske T,Gjevik E,et al.Individual characteristics of students with autism spectrum disorders and school refusal behavior[J].Autism,2017,23(2):1-11.
[21] NayakA,Sangoi B,Nachane H. School refusal behavior in Indian children:Analysis of clinical profile,psychopathology and development of a best-fit risk assessment model[J].Indian J Pediatr,2018,85(12):1073-1078.
[22] Carolina,G,Kearney CA,Jiménez-Ayala CE,et al.Functional profiles of school refusal behavior and their relationship with depression,anxiety,and stress[J].Psychiat Res,2018,269:140-144.
[23] Finning K,Ukoumunne OC,Ford T,et al.Review:The association between anxiety and poor attendance at school-a systematic review[J].Child Adolesc Ment Health,2019,24(3):205-216.
[24] 李刚,杨孝,李启洪. 拒绝上学儿童青少年家庭环境和父母养育方式调查研究[J].精神医学杂志,2017,30(6):424-427
[25] Gonzálvez C,Díaz-Herrero A,Sanmartín R,et al.Identifying risk profiles of school refusal behavior:Differences in social anxiety and family functioning among Spanish adolescents[J].Int J Environ Res Publ Health,2019,16(19):3731.
[26] 朱丽,程丽,高桦,等. 家庭环境对青少年拒学心理特征的影响[J].安徽医药,2021,25(8):1537-1540.
[27] Ingles CJ,Garcia-Fernandez JM,Marzo JC,et al.School Anxiety Inventory-Short Version:Factorial invariance and latent mean differences across gender and age in Spanish adolescents[J].Meas Eval Couns Dev,2015,48(4):247-265.
[28] Havik T,Bru E,ErtesväG SK. School factors associated with school refusal- and truancy-related reasons for school non-attendance[J].Soc Psychol Educ,2015,18(2):221-240.
[29] Sorrenti L,Filippello P,Buzzai C,et al.School refusal in students with low academic performances and specific learning disorder. The role of self-esteem and perceived parental psychological control[J].Int J Disabil Dev Ed,2019(2):1-16.
[30] Gonzálvez C,N Díaz-Herrero A,Sanmartín R,et al.Testing the functional profiles of school refusal behavior and clarifying their relationship with school anxiety[J].Front Public Health,2020,8:598915.
[31] Luana S,Pina F,Susanna O,et al.Learned helplessness and learning goals:Role played in school refusal. A study on Italian students[J].MJCP,2016,4(2).doi:10.6092/2282-1619/2016.4.1235
[32] Maeda T,Oniki K,Miike T. Sleep education in primary school prevents future school refusal behavior[J].Pediatr Int,2019,61(10):1036-1042.
[33] Terada S,Matsumoto Y,Sato T,et al.School refusal by patients with gender identity disorder[J].Gen Hosp Psychiat,2012,34(3):299-303.
[34] FukuyaY,Matsuyama Y,Isumi A,et al.Toothbrushing and school refusal in elementary school:A longitudinal study[J].Int J Environ Res Pub Health,2020,17(20):7505.
[35] Strmbeck J,Palmér R,Lax IS,et al.Outcome of a multi-modal CBT-based treatment program for chronic school refusal[J].Glob Pediatr Health,2021,8:2333794X2110029.
[36] Elliott JG,Place M. Practitioner review:School refusal:Developments in conceptualisation and treatment since 2000[J].J Child Psychol Psyc,2019,60(1):4-15.
[37] Melvin GA,Dudley AL,Gordon MS,et al.Augmenting cognitive behavior therapy for school refusal with fluoxetine:A randomized controlled trial[J].Child Psychiatr Hum Dev,2017,48(3):485-497.
[38] Tobon AL,Reed MO,Taylor JH,et al.A systematic review of pharmacologic treatments for school refusal behavior[J].J Child Adol Psychop,2018,28(6):368-378.
[39] Prabhuswamy M,Srinath S,Girimaji S,et al.Outcome of children with school refusal[J].Indian J Pediatr,2007,74(4):375-379.
[40] Korematsu S,Takano T,Izumi T. Pre-school development and behavior screening with a consecutive support programs for 5-year-olds reduces the rate of school refusal[J].Brain Dev-Jpn,2016,38(4):373-376.
[41] Mohamed EM. Using a preventive social work program for reducing school refusal[J].Child Sch,2017,39(2):81-88.