Meta-analysis on the effect of music therapy on children with autism spectrum disorder

doi:10.11852/zgetbjzz2018-1147

Abstract

Abstract: Objective To evaluate the effect of music therapy on children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) systematically, in order to provide evidence for further rehabilitation of ASD children. Methods Randomized controlled trial studies on the effect of music therapy on ASD children from 2000 to 2017 were analyzed by Meta-analysis with Rev Man 5.3 software. The fixed effect model or random effect model was selected by the heterogeneity test results. The SMD value and 95%CI were calculated, publication bias was evaluated, and sensitivity analysis was conducted. Subgroup analysis was conducted according to different duration time of intervention. Results Totally 20 published articles were selected, including 614 intervention cases and 622 control cases. The values of SMD and 95%CI of music therapy for overall effect of ASD children were of statistical significance(SMD=－0.74, 95%CI:－1.14－－0.34, P＜0.001). Also, music therapy improved social interaction skills(SMD=－0.81, 95%CI:－1.08－－0.54, P＜0.001), language function(SMD=－0.57,95%CI:－0.84－－0.29, P＜0.001) and language communication(SMD= 0.92,95%CI:0.41－1.44,P＜0.001)of ASD children significantly except for social behaviors (SMD=－0.85,95%CI:－0.61-0.03,P＞0.05). Subgroup analysis showed that music therapy did not significantly improve non-language communication skills of ASD children(SMD=0.45,95%CI:－0.11－1.01,P=0.12). Conclusions Music therapy has positive effect on core symptoms of ASD children, including the overall effect, social interaction, language function and language communication. However, it is suggested to combine music therapy with other comprehensive intervention and education interventions instead of conducting music therapy alone. Meanwhile, individualized and comprehensive interventions are expected according to the different symptoms of ASD children, in order to promote their better rehabilitation.

Key words: music therapy, autism spectrum disorder, randomized controlled trials, Meta-analysis

摘要： 目的系统评价音乐疗法对孤独症谱系障碍(ASD)患儿干预效果,以期为ASD的康复训练提供参考。方法运用Rev Man 5.3软件,对2000年1月1日—2017年12月31日国内外发表的有关音乐疗法对ASD患儿干预的随机对照试验研究进行Meta分析,根据异质性检验结果选择固定效应模型或随机效应模型,计算SMD值及95%CI,评估发表偏倚,进行敏感性分析和亚组分析。结果最终纳入20篇文献,累计干预组614例,对照组622例。合并效应量结果显示,音乐疗法对ASD患儿的总体效果显著(SMD=－0.74,95%CI:－1.14~－0.34,P＜0.001),可提高患儿的社会交往能力(SMD=－0.81,95%CI:－1.08~－0.54,P＜0.001),语言功能(SMD=－0.57,95%CI:－0.84~－0.29,P＜0.001),语言交流能力(SMD=0.92,95%CI:0.41~1.44,P＜0.001),但对ASD患儿社会行为的干预效果不显著(SMD=－0.85,95%CI:－0.61~0.03,P＞0.05)。亚组分析显示,音乐疗法对ASD患儿非语言交流能力改善不显著(SMD=0.45,95%CI:－0.11~1.01,P=0.12)。结论音乐疗法能够改善ASD患儿总体效果、社会交往、语言功能和语言交流能力。不鼓励单独使用音乐疗法来管理ASD患儿的核心特征,但音乐疗法可作为其他综合行为和教育干预计划组成的一部分。同时应针对ASD患儿的具体表现采取个性化的整合方案。

关键词: 音乐疗法, 孤独症谱系障碍, 随机对照试验, Meta分析

CLC Number:

R749.93

WANG Yue, LEI Xiao-mei, YANG Yuan-yuan, LI Shao-wen. Meta-analysis on the effect of music therapy on children with autism spectrum disorder[J]. journal1, 2019, 27(1): 66-72.

王悦, 雷晓梅, 杨媛媛, 李少闻. 音乐疗法对孤独症谱系障碍患儿干预效果的Meta分析[J]. 中国儿童保健杂志, 2019, 27(1): 66-72.

References

[1] American Pediatrics Association. Diagnostic the statistical manual of mental disorders:DSM-5[M]. Washington DC:American Pediatrics Association, 2013.
[2] 刘贤,林穗方,陈文雄,等.中国儿童孤独症谱系障碍患病率Meta分析[J].中国儿童保健杂志,2018,26(4):402-406.
[3] 郝伟.精神病学[M].北京:人民卫生出版社,2005:186-187.
[4] 杜亚松.孤独谱系障碍非药物治疗进展[J].中国儿童保健杂志, 2017, 25(12):1189-1191.
[5] Geretsegger M, Elefant C, Mössler KA, et al. Music therapy for people with autism spectrum disorder [J]. Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2014, 6:CD004381.
[6] Bieleninik L, Geretsegger M, Mössler KA, et al. Effects of improvisational music therapy vs enhanced standard care on symptom severity among children with autism spectrum disorder:the TIME-A randomized clinical trial [J]. JAMA, 2017, 318(6):525-535.
[7] 刘鸣.系统评价、Meta分析设计与实施方法[M].北京:人民卫生出版社,2011.
[8] 张改巧,龚群,张凤玲,等.听觉统合训练对儿童孤独症的疗效评估[J].北京大学学报:医学版,2009,41(4):426-431.
[9] 张俊,张勤良. 听觉统合训练对孤独症儿童康复效果研究[J].中国儿童保健杂志,2014,22(3):321-324.
[10] 孤独症儿童听觉统合训练的疗效[J].中国实用医药, 2012, 7(4):30-31.
[11] 孙玉燕,黄春娟,刘健,等.低功能孤独症患儿听觉统合训练疗效研究及心理护理[J].中国现代医生,2014,52(9):37-40.
[12] 陈蕾,张雅如,邵智,等.以社交故事为主要内容的音乐疗法干预孤独症儿童的疗效观察[J].中华物理医学与康复杂志,2013,35(7):575-578.
[13] 王璟,张旭亚,张金丽.音乐疗法对儿童孤独症的影响[J].河南大学学报:医学版,2009,28(1):60-61.
[14] 刘刚. 针刺配合音乐疗法治疗自闭症的临床观察和实验研究[D]. 广州:广州中医药大学,2006.
[15] 周青蕊, 景玉珍, 甘晓燕,等. 音乐治疗对儿童孤独症谱系障碍的康复效果[J]. 中国初级卫生保健, 2017, 31(5):68-69.
[16] 李瑞玲, 杨晓艳, 曹春红. 音乐疗法结合语言训练对孤独症儿童语言康复的疗效观察[J]. 中国听力语言康复科学杂志, 2016, 14(3):220-223.
[17] 刘振寰, 李诺. 音乐治疗配合头针疗法治疗自闭症[C]//中国音乐治疗学会第十届学术年会论文集. 广州:中国音乐治疗学会, 2011.
[18] Corbett BA, Shickman K, Ferrer E. Brief report:the effects of Tomatis sound therapy on language in children with autism[J]. J Autism Dev Disord, 2008, 38(3):562-566.
[19] Lim HA. Effect of "developmental speech and language training through music" on speech production in children with autism spectrum disorders[J]. J Music Ther, 2010, 47(1):2-26.
[20] Alberta LA. Effects of auditory integration training on receptive and expressive language in adolescents with autism spectrum disorders[D]. Ann Arbor:The William Paterson University of New Jersey, 2008.
[21] Schwartzberg ET, Silverman MJ. Effects of music-based social stories on comprehension and generalization of social skills in children with autism spectrum disorders:a randomized effectiveness study[J]. Arts in Psychotherapy, 2013, 40(3):331-337.
[22] Thompson GA, Mcferran KS, Gold C. Family-centred music therapy to promote social engagement in young children with severe autism spectrum disorder:a randomized controlled study [J]. Child Care Health Dev, 2014, 40(6):840-852.
[23] Farmer KJ. The effect of music vs. nonmusic paired with gestures on spontaneous verbal and nonverbal communication skills of children with autism ages 1-5[D]. Tallahassee:Florida State University,2003.
[24] Gattino GS, Rudimar dos Santos RR, Dânae L, et al. Effects of relational music therapy on communication of children with autism:a randomized controlled study[J]. Nordic Journal of Music Therapy, 2011, 20(2):142-154.
[25] Ghasemtabar SN, Hosseini M, Fayyaz I, et al. Music therapy:an effective approach in improving social skills of children with autism[J]. Adv Biomed Res, 2015,4:157.
[26] LaGasse AB.Effects of a music therapy group intervention on enhancing social skills in children with autism[J].J Music Ther,2014,51(3):250-275.
[27] 高天. 音乐治疗导论[M]. 北京:世界图书出版公司, 2009.
[28] Allen R, Davis R, Hill E. The effects of autism and alexithymia on physiological and verbal responsiveness to music[J]. J Autism Dev Disord, 2013,43(2):432-444.